tailor fails to apply changeset 193 of typo.leetsoft.com correctly

[anonymous]

Tailorizing the svn repo typo.leetsoft.com fails to apply changeset 193 when started from revision =< 171. If started from 172 or later (but before 193 of course) the same changeset is applied correctly.

tailor --verbose --debug --configfile=typo.bzr.tailor
16:17:35 [I] Bootstrapping "project" in "/home/bart/tmp/typo.new"
16:17:35 [I] Initializing new repository in "/home/bart/tmp/typo.new"...
16:17:35 [I] $ svn ls svn://leetsoft.com/typo
branches/
tags/
trunk/
16:17:44 [I] [Ok]
16:17:44 [I] $ svn ls svn://leetsoft.com
svn: No repository found in 'svn://leetsoft.com'
16:17:46 [W] [Status 1]
16:17:46 [I] $ svn co --quiet --revision 171 svn://leetsoft.com/typo/trunk /home/bart/tmp/typo.new
16:17:58 [I] [Ok]
16:17:58 [I] /home/bart/tmp/typo.new $ svn log --verbose --xml --revision 171

[snip]

16:20:04 [I] /home/bart/tmp/typo.new $ svn update --revision 193 .
16:20:07 [I] [Ok]
Output stream:
U    db/schema.mysql.sql
U    db/schema.psql.sql
U    db/schema.sqlite.sql
U    README
D    README_LOGIN
Updated to revision 193.
16:20:07 [I] _replayChangeset: changeset=
README UPD
db/schema.mysql.sql UPD
db/schema.psql.sql UPD
db/schema.sqlite.sql UPD
16:20:07 [I] Committing "[project @ 193]"...
16:20:07 [I] -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
16:20:07 [I] Changeset "194"
.....

Note how in the above output, the file README_LOGIN is listed as deleted in the output stream of svn changeset 193 but that the same file isn't listed in the tailor changeset (reporting the files in the tailor changeset is mine). The README_LOGIN file was added in revision 172.

When starting at revision 172, changeset 193 does get applied correctly as the following log shows.

tailor --verbose --debug --configfile=typo.bzr.tailor
16:09:38 [I] Bootstrapping "project" in "/home/bart/tmp/typo.new"
16:09:41 [I] Initializing new repository in "/home/bart/tmp/typo.new"...
16:09:41 [I] $ svn ls svn://leetsoft.com/typo
svn: Can't connect to host 'leetsoft.com': Connection timed out
16:13:04 [W] [Status 1]
16:13:04 [I] $ svn ls svn://leetsoft.com

svn: No repository found in 'svn://leetsoft.com'
16:13:05 [W] [Status 1]
16:13:05 [I] $ svn co --quiet --revision 172 svn://leetsoft.com/typo/trunk /home/bart/tmp/typo.new
16:13:19 [I] [Ok]
16:13:19 [I] /home/bart/tmp/typo.new $ svn log --verbose --xml --revision 172

[snip]

16:15:08 [I] /home/bart/tmp/typo.new $ svn update --revision 193 .
16:15:12 [I] [Ok]
Output stream:
U    db/schema.mysql.sql
U    db/schema.psql.sql
U    db/schema.sqlite.sql
U    README
D    README_LOGIN
Updated to revision 193.
16:15:12 [I] _replayChangeset: changeset=
README UPD
README_LOGIN DEL
db/schema.mysql.sql UPD
db/schema.psql.sql UPD
db/schema.sqlite.sql UPD
16:15:12 [I] Removing README_LOGIN...
16:15:12 [I] Committing "[project @ 193]"...
16:15:14 [I] -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*
16:15:14 [I] Changeset "194"
...

[lele]

Uhm, I cannot see what could interfere here... I shall try out the conversion myself and dig a little. BTW, why wasn't str(changeset) enough for debugging purposes?

[bartt]

str(changeset) wasn't enough because it didn't clearly report what type of change (UPD, DEL, ..) would be applied for each file in the changeset.

[bartt]

Tailor config file for this conversion:

[DEFAULT]
verbose = True

[project]
target = bzr:target
start-revision = INITIAL
root-directory = /tmp/typo.bzr
state-file = tailor.state
source = svn:source
subdir = .

[bzr:target]

[svn:source]
module = /trunk
repository = svn://leetsoft.com/typo

[lele]

I found the reason of the problem: it's related to changes introduced in [840] and [841] that I'm currently trying to understand and fix.

[lele]

This seems to be fixed by [1048]